ASK DR. BOLI.

Dear Dr. Boli: Why do laws exist? —Sincerely, Samantha in Mr. McRoberts’ Fifth-Period Civics Class, and if you could get me an answer before the bell rings that would really help.

Dear Miss: You will hear two completely incompatible theories about why laws exist. The idealists will say that laws exist to protect the poor and humble from the depredations of the powerful. The cynics will say that laws exist to maintain the ascendancy of the powerful over the poor and humble.

However, the real answer is much more pragmatic. Laws exist to give legislators something to do, thus keeping them off the streets. If you have ever met an average state legislator, you know that this is a necessary and laudable goal.

Comments

  1. KevinT says:

    The poor girl… if the laws already exist, the legislators are unnecessary. Mr. McRoberts is going to have her tied up in a logic quandary for the remainder of class time.

    • Dr. Boli says:

      Legislators are always necessary, because all the laws made by the previous session of the legislature are wrong. A legislator’s chief duty is to repudiate the work of previous legislators.

  2. P.J. O’Rourke once joked that the primary purpose of the US Senate is to take the top 100 prominent numbskulls and keep them out of positions where they could do real damage. And thus prominent US corporations were spared the horror of Paul Wellstone as CEO. Although I guess now we’d have to update that to Ted Cruz, Tom Cotton, and Sheldon Whitehouse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *